(Photo: Glen MacLarty/Flickr.)
Curry is a popular dish to use as an introduction to eating goat. (Photo: Glen MacLarty/Flickr.)

Food Republic’s column Ask Your Butcher seeks to answer FAQs in the world of butchery. Ethically minded butcher Bryan Mayer has opened butcher shops and restaurants and has trained butchers in the U.S. and abroad. He helped develop the renowned butcher-training program at Fleishers, where he is currently director of butchery education. In each column, Mayer tackles a pressing issue facing both meat buyers and home cooks. This week, he takes on a type of meat that he finds to be underutilized in U.S. kitchens.

October is firmly in our rearview mirror, or as some of the food-marketing folks like to call it, “Goatober.” I’m here to tell you, however, that goat is something that can be enjoyed no matter what month it is. Whether you grill, braise or roast it, eating goat meat is something to be enjoyed year-round.

Goat is still a very small part of the meat industry in the U.S., but it has shown signs of growing over the past decade. The reason? Well, simply, goat meat is delicious. Sure, we are all very well aware of goats as a source of milk for dairy products or as fiber for their hides, but eating goat meat is something that we should all appreciate. The last few sentences alone should clue you in on how purposeful raising goats can be, as they can not only feed us but also keep us warm! And let’s not forget that goat meat is consumed throughout the majority of the world.

Sure, goat suffers from a few negative connotations, not least of which is the phrase “old goat,” but if you have been a reader of this column for any length of time, we champion the flavor of older, more mature animals. So is the old goat really that bad? I think not!

So let’s talk a little about eating goat meat and dispel some myths along the way.

Photo: Ben Fink
Island-style curried goat stew. (Photo: Ben Fink.)

Eating Goat

The demand for goat meat in the U.S. is far greater than the supply. Our ever-increasing population of cultures that frequently eat goat meat is the main driver. However, despite the demand, producers in the U.S. face many challenges. Goats are seasonal breeders, and that poses problems in supplying the market with consistent, quality product. Coupled with the difficulty of obtaining goat meat through retail markets, it’s more difficult for you, the consumer, to obtain goat outside of private channels, farmers’ markets or on-farm sales. Goat just doesn’t have the clout that other meats have…yet!

But what if I told you that goat meat is extremely nutritious, with high amounts of protein and iron? Okay, maybe now you’re listening. And maybe lamb just isn’t your thing and for some reason you’re stuck on goat being too similar. Well, that’s just not true. In fact, goat meat has a flavor profile that’s more similar to beef. Not to talk down on lamb — you should totally eat lamb.

You’ve heard me talk about why you should eat veal. Well, you should be eating goat meat for the same reasons. They are incredibly sustainable, dual-purpose animals. The goat dairy industry generates a large number of kids (baby goats). Dairy farmers have no need for males and keep only some females. We need to put these surplus animals to use in the food chain. And it’s not just about eating kid goat. Sure, we value tenderness and, of course, the lack of flavor that comes from such young animals, for some reason. But the full flavor of a mature goat can be just as rewarding as a culled dairy cow, mutton or sow. That means flavor, folks!

Okay, if I have to, I’ll say it. You can cook goat much in the same way you cook lamb. There, does that make you feel more comfortable? Yes, you can have chops. Sure, you can roast a leg. And of course, you can braise it and even curry it if you want. The most important thing is that you’re buying goat from a butcher or farmer that you trust, who has raised them out on pasture and allowed them to graze and forage and eat what they are supposed to eat!

So with that in mind, how about a recipe or two?

Let’s skip the chops and go directly to my favorite parts, the legs and shoulders. And contrary to what you may think, roasting and braising are about the easiest ways to cook. Season, let sit overnight in your fridge, turn your oven on and let cook. You’ll use a probe thermometer to make sure you get to the desired temp, and we’ll spice minimally to make sure we don’t mask that great goat taste.

Roasted Goat Leg

(Photo: John Hahn/Facebook.)
Leg of goat. (Photo: John Hahn/Facebook.)

1 five- to seven-pound fully pastured, whole goat leg, bone in, aitchbone off
4 cloves of garlic
2 tablespoons salt
1 tablespoon paprika
1 teaspoon pepper
3 tablespoons lemon juice
½ cup olive oil


  1. Mix your dry ingredients thoroughly and then add your wet ingredients. Make sure everything is mixed well together into a paste. If there’s a decent amount of fat covering, score down until you reach the muscle. Be careful not to cut into the muscle. We want to give the paste (mostly the salt) a chance to season and tenderize the meat overnight, and that fat will act as a barrier.
  2. Tightly wrap the goat leg in plastic wrap so the pate stays in contact with the leg and place in your fridge overnight.
  3. Some folks like to start high, at 400°F, and then kick the oven temp down to 325°F after 20 minutes or so and continue to cook until desired doneness. Some start low, around 325°F, and kick it up at the end. I’m a middle-of-the-road kind of guy — the gray area. I start at 300°F and I leave it there. Simple. That lower oven temp will allow for a much more even cook. We’ll keep that probe thermometer in and pull our roast when it’s 130°-135°F. Let it rest for about 15 minutes and then carve away!

Tip: Make sure your butcher ties your goat leg. This will give you a relatively even shape and help it cook more evenly. Or, if you’re up for the challenge, watch our roast-tying video

Braised Goat Shoulder

(Photo: World's Best Pan/Facebook.)
Goat shoulder. (Photo: World’s Best Pan/Facebook.)

1 five- to seven-pound fully pastured goat shoulder, bone out
3 cups red wine (roughly the whole bottle, so get one for you to drink as well)
1 cup water
2 cups shallots, peeled
6 gloves garlic crushed/peeled
1 bay leaf
2 tablespoons salt
4 tablespoons vegetable oil


  1. Have your butcher (or you can, if you’re feeling up for the challenge) debone the shoulder and remove any glands. Season the shoulder with salt and allow to sit in your fridge overnight.
  2. Place a Dutch oven over medium heat and wait until the oil starts to shimmer, not smoke.
  3. Brown the shoulder on all sides, making sure to scrape down the bottom of your Dutch oven to remove all those little bits and pieces that stick to the bottom. Add your shallots and garlic and cook those down over medium heat for another 10 minutes to get that caramelization. Meanwhile, your oven is preheating to 300°F. Add in your wine, water and the rest of your spices, bring to a simmer and then off into your oven for roughly three hours. It should be fork tender but not falling apart. We want to slice it.
  4. When the shoulder is done, remove it from your Dutch oven, and reduce the remaining liquid over medium heat to create your sauce. It’s ready when it coats the back of the spoon.

Tip: Feel free to add any vegetables to your stew — potatoes, carrots, mushrooms, etc., making sure to account for variations in cooking time. We don’t want the texture of mush!